We love getting recommendations, and we have gotten quite a bit from Trumbull County. I have gotten many messages saying Trumbull County has legit quality Youngstown Pizza.
Niki'z Pub in Niles was one of the most recommended places we got.
Robbin's Ave Pizza in Niles (2 minutes away) was another highly recommended spot
Here is our review of Niki'z Pub, and Robbin's Ave Pizza will be next. We are not from Niles so we do not know if there is a Wedgewood/Westgate type rivalry here or not. Being so close to one another we would think there is a decent amount of debate over who has the better pie.